On a quiet patch of Smith’s Island, amid Bermuda’s subtropical foliage and limestone terrain, maritime archaeologist Xander Cook is helping to rewrite the island’s early colonial history—one sherd of flint and one carved posthole at a time.

Xander Cook

Cook, a Bermudian PhD candidate at Cardiff University, is spearheading research that reveals an overlooked chapter in the island’s past: the presence and persistence of Native American people in Bermuda’s early settlement period. His work builds on over a decade of excavation at the Oven Site and Smallpox Bay—two archaeological digs on Smith’s Island that have yielded material evidence of Native American craftsmanship, cultural endurance, and colonial entanglement.

“We found worked flint—pieces shaped deliberately using traditional Native techniques,” Cook says. “Bermuda doesn’t have flint or similar stone, so it had to be brought here. That’s our first clue.”

In 2010, historian Dr. Michael Jarvis—author of In the Eye of All Trade—first investigated Smith’s Island and identified a 17th-century house site marked by a primitive oven carved into the bedrock. The site became known as the Oven Site. In subsequent years, excavations uncovered fire-blackened soil, bone-handled tools, and lithic debris associated with toolmaking.

A turning point came when archival records surfaced: an 18th-century inventory belonging to Boaz Sharpe, a resident of Smith’s Island, which listed several enslaved Native Americans, including a child that was only 2 days old. Cook and Jarvis began connecting the dots. “If these individuals brought flint with them—or repurposed stone ballast from ships—they were likely teaching their children traditional skills,” says Cook.

This research challenges long-held assumptions that Bermuda’s early enslaved population consisted exclusively of Africans. Instead, it paints a broader, more complex picture of forced migration and cultural survival across the Atlantic.

Nearby at Smallpox Bay, an 1780/90’s British quarantine site for yellow fever and smallpox, excavation teams uncovered dozens of carved postholes. These were likely the foundations of substantial timber buildings predating the settlement of St. George’s. Among the artefacts: fragments of Bellarmine flasks—bulbous German jugs with bearded faces on the necks, often brought as heirlooms by early settlers. “These are some of my favourite finds,” Cook says with a smile. “They’re beautiful, eerie, and unmistakably tied to that first wave of colonisation.”

Team working on Smith’s Island

The evidence from Smith’s Island suggests that Bermuda’s first European-style dwellings—and possibly its first church—were built there before St. George’s was fully established. The settlement likely ran in tandem with Jamestown, Virginia, and may have been home to a more diverse population than history books suggest.

What became of the Native Americans brought to Bermuda remains unclear. “Like so many enslaved peoples, their voices weren’t recorded,” Cook notes. “But oral traditions survived.” For centuries, Bermudians from St. David’s were colloquially called “Mohawks,” a misnomer that masked the diversity of Indigenous lineages. Now, DNA research has confirmed that some St. David’s families descend from tribes such as the Pequot and Wampanoag and other Algonquin nations along the East coast.

Cook’s work underscores not only the significance of archaeological discovery, but also the urgency of preserving Bermuda’s terrestrial heritage. While Bermuda has strong laws protecting underwater shipwrecks, its land-based archaeological policies remain underdeveloped. One of Cook’s long-term goals is to establish a formal archaeological unit for the island—one that can respond when historical material is uncovered during construction or land development.

“Archaeology is inherently destructive,” he explains. “Once you dig, you can’t go back. So recording everything thoroughly is key. But we need the framework and legislation to do that responsibly.”

Until recently, the dig on Smith’s Island was federally funded through U.S. academic grants awarded to University of Rochester through Dr. Michael Jarvis. However, Cook says that funding was cut during the Trump administration, stalling many small-scale digs. It is hoped that support from Bermuda’s Department of Culture and private donors will keep research, like what Cook & Jarvis are doing, alive.

“This isn’t just about the past—it’s about reclaiming our own unique Bermudian story,” Cook says. “The more we learn, the more we can teach, and the more connected Bermudians can feel to the layers of history beneath their feet.”