The Bermudian takes a look back at Bermuda’s greatest footballers, their stats, and their contributions to the Beautiful Game.

You probably know who is on the list, but who is the greatest among them is a subject that demands debate.

So without further ado…


Randolph Horton

Original star of the New York Cosmos 

Position: Forward

Height: 6’ 2”

Weight: Not available

“In a league that would soon binge on famous footballers, the Bermuda international forward was one of NASL’s most recognisable figures.”

 Career Stats

1966-1970Somerset TrojansN/AN/A
1970Phiadelphia UkraniansN/AN/A
1971-1974New York Cosmos5229
1975Washington Diplomats187
1976Hartford Bitentennials41
Total93 52



Career Highlights


Signed with the New York Cosmos for the team’s inaugural season in the North American Soccer League.

Scored the team’s first ever goal on his debut.

Led the Cosmos to 4th place overall. Top goalscorer for the team with 16.

NASL Rookie of the Year

First Team All-Star

Led the Cosmos to the NASL playoff finals, beating the St Louis Stars.

Led the league with 9 goals (13 overall)


First Team All-Star (alongside a certain Montreal Olypique midfielder named Graeme Souness.)

While the ’72 season would be the pinnacle of Randy’s career, his four years with the Cosmos would see him become one of the stars of the league.

Finished in 3rd place after going out to the Dallas Tornados in the playoff semifinals.

Finished as the Cosmos’ top goal scorer with 9, but the team would finish a disappointing 13th place overall. Randy left for the Washington Diplomats the following season.

Some Brazilian guy would join the Cosmos in ’75, but he’s not important. Randy is important.





Shaun Goater

Position: Forward

Height: 5’11”

Weight: 163 lbs

“The Bermudan striker will forever be remembered for helping to shine some light on a desperately dark period in the club’s history.” – Anthony Jepson, Manchester Evening News


Career Stats

1989Manchester United00
1989-1996Rotherham United20970
1996-1998Bristol City7540
1998-2003Manchester City189103
2005-2006Southend United3311
2007-2008Bermuda Hogges93
2008-2010North Village Rams71

Career Highlights:

Scouted by Manchester United at 17 years old in Bermuda. Offered his first professional contract after flying to England for a trial.

Signed for Rotherham United in order to gain first team experience after not breaking into the squad at Manchester United.

Led Rotherham to win the Auto Windscreens Shield

Moved to Bristol City for a fee of £175,000.

Named in the PFA Team of the Year for the second division, scoring 45 goals in 81 appearances.

Signed for Manchester City on transfer deadline day for £400,000.

Ended the season as City’s top goalscorer with 21 goals. The 21st goal was scored in a play-off semi-final against Wigan Athletic, sending Manchester City to Wembley Stadium for a playoff final which saw City promoted to the Second Division after a penalty s

The song “Feed the Goat and he Will Score” starts ringing around the Maine Road grounds.

Finished the club’s top goal score again, this time with 29 goals, leading Manchester City to the club’s second straight promotion.

Made his first appearance in top flight football at the age of 30. Once established in the first team, Goater was Manchester City’s top goalscorer for the third consecutive season, but his 11 goals could not save the team from relegation.

City were promoted as champions, and he was the club’s top scorer for the fourth time in a row, as well as being the top scorer in the division.

Became the first Manchester City player since Francis Lee in 1972 to score more than 30 goals in a season.

Started just 14 games, but scored seven goals, including his 99th and 100th for the club against Manchester United. In February 2003, Goater struck against the same opposition to score the fastest goal by a substitute in Premier League history, just 9 seconds after coming onto the pitch. (Click the links to see the goals)

Shortly before the end of the season, Goater announced his intention to leave Manchester City when the season finished in order to seek regular first team football. In his final match for Manchester City, he was asked to captain the side in the team’s final game at Maine Road.

Signed with Reading on 1 August. Chairman John Madejski described the transfer as “the biggest in Reading Football Club’s history”. The manager that signed him, Alan Pardew, would leave shortly after. Goatee would never be a part of the new manager’s future plans, and would only play four times in his final season with the team in 2004.

Deciding to postpone his retirement, signed with League One club Southend United. Helps the team to a second straight promotion, scoring 11 goals.

Made his final professional appearance on May 6 against Bristol City, his former club. The crowd included an estimated 400 Manchester City fans who travelled to Southend to mark the occasion.


Clyde Best

 Team: West Ham
Position: Forward
Height: 6′ 2”
Weight: 195 lbs.

“Bermuda-born Clyde Best… became the first black player to establish himself in the English top flight…” – CNN

Career Stats

1968-1976West Ham United21858
1975Tampa Bay Rowdies (loan)196
1976Tampa Bay Rowdies (indoor)47
1976Tampa Bay Rowdies199
1977-1981Portland Timbers11838
1979-1980Cleveland Force (indoor)3033
1980-1981Portland Timbers (indoor)62
1981-1982Toronto Blizzard222
1981-1982Toronto Blizzard (indoor)183
1982-1984Los Angeles Lazers (indoor)9029

Career Highlights

(Information on Best’s career that can be broken down like I’ve done above is harder to come by, so forgive the sparseness.)

First capped for the Bermuda national team at the age of 15.

Made his debut on August 25 in a League Cup match against Halifax Town (4-2, one goal by Best).

In those days West Ham had class players like Bobby Moore, Trevor Brooking, Billy Bonds and Geoff Hurst. It was his partnership with Hurst that really helped Best raise his game.

His most prolific season by far, scoring 17 league goals (one of which you can see here) and playing all 42 league matches.

A quick look at his company atop the league’s top scoring chart gives you a sense of just how good Best was that season, even if he wasn’t the most graceful at times.

April 1, 1971 vs Tottenham Best, Clive Charles and Ade Coker become the time three black players to ever feature in an English Division One team.

Hurst leaves for Stoke City, and the goals begin to dry up for Best. By ’75, when West Ham won the FA Cup and reached the final of the European Cup for Cup Winners in ’76, Best was no longer the first choice striker.

Best leaves England for the NASL to get more play time, immediately leading the Tampa Bay Rowdies to the championship, scoring the decisive second goal in a 2-0 victory in the final against the Portland Timbers.

Best joins Dutch club Feyenoord in a bid to get back into European football. Best scored only three goals in 23 league matches.

Best joins indoor team the Cleveland Force. He’d continue playing in Major Indoor Soccer League before finally retiring in 1984.

While his numbers are not as impressive as Goater’s, Best’s affect on the game as a black
pioneer puts him heads above the competition. Without him, Goater’s career might not have been possible.

“One of the instances that will always stick in my mind,” said Mr Best. “I got a letter in the mail one day, and we were playing at home, I can’t remember the particular team, but the letter stated that I when I came through the tunnel they were going to throw acid in my face.”

“It was hard, it was tough. And I found most times the best way to silence most of the people was to put the ball in the back of the net.”