Good Friday in Bermuda has a distinct sound and a smell.

The sound is wooden kites rattling in the wind and line humming off a spool. The smell—coming out of kitchens before anyone heads for the beach—is salt cod, potatoes, and thyme hitting hot oil. Codfish cakes are built for that day: small enough to hold in one hand, sturdy enough to eat standing up, and salty enough to make you reach for something sweet—usually a hot cross bun.

That pairing can feel timeless, but the codfish cake is less “ancient Bermudian fish dish” than it is an edible snapshot of Bermuda’s Atlantic history: trade routes that ran from Caribbean salt ponds to North Atlantic cod fisheries; the economics of preserved food before refrigeration; and a holiday culture that turned a practical staple into a ritual.

Start with the obvious contradiction: cod isn’t fished in Bermuda. A Bermudian cultural study guide puts it plainly, then explains why it’s here anyway—Bermudian mariners raked salt in the Turks Islands in the 17th century, carried that salt north to sell into codfish businesses, and returned with salted cod that became a staple in Bermuda.

In other words, the codfish cake begins as supply chain logic. Salt makes fish portable. Portable fish becomes food. And once a food is reliable, it becomes tradition.

Turks & Caicos sources describe Bermudians arriving in the 1660s to rake salt and developing the trade over the next centuries—salt that shipped out to North Atlantic markets. The National Museum of Bermuda describes that same system from Bermuda’s side: salt harvested in the Turks moved through Bermudian shipping, and cod moved back in the opposite direction, feeding markets across the Atlantic world.

The museum’s point isn’t just commerce; it’s what commerce made possible. Salted, dried cod could survive heat and time. That durability helped cod become a cheap, scalable protein in plantation economies, where enslaved labourers were provisioned at minimal cost—an ugly but central part of how Atlantic food commodities worked.

There’s a tendency to treat “traditional foods” as innocent—just family, just nostalgia. Bermuda’s cod traditions don’t really allow that. The same museum essay that celebrates Good Friday codfish cakes also asks readers to “reflect upon the history of this food and the experiences of those whose back-breaking work brought it to our tables,” linking the tradition to coerced labour systems that underwrote salt production and the broader cod economy.

Academic work on Bermuda’s Atlantic world adds another dimension: Bermudians weren’t only consumers and traders; they also tried to enter the Newfoundland fishery directly. Jeff A. Webb’s study of the 1788 Bermudian–Newfoundland episode shows how law and access to shore-based processing shaped who could profit from cod—and how deeply cod sat inside imperial rules and colonial competition.

So how do you get from “salted cod as a staple” to codfish cakes—the specific form Bermudians now treat as essential Good Friday fare?

Technique is the bridge. A Bermudian foodways guide describes the basic architecture: soaked salt cod, mashed potato, onion, parsley, and thyme, bound with egg, coated in flour, fried until golden. It also notes the key cultural detail: recipes vary island-wide, but “lots of thyme” is non-negotiable.

A 15 April 1992 Royal Gazette piece framed codfish cakes and hot cross buns as “as much a part of the Bermuda Good Friday as kite flying,” specifically noting how practical they are to eat while flying a kite—one hand for food, one for the string.

By 7 April 1993, the paper was calling hot cross buns and codfish cakes the Good Friday “musts” of Bermuda Easter.

Those dates matter because they show the tradition in public print: not just “people do this,” but “this is what Good Friday means here.”

Once a dish moves from kitchen memory into cookbooks and newspaper recipe pages, it hardens into something like public heritage.

In the 1990s, The Royal Gazette repeatedly published codfish cake recipes and variations—some attributed to local cookbooks and community collections, others tied to named figures. A 21 March 1997 recipe roundup printed a standard version, plus “Chef Fred Ming’s” version (notably enriched with butter) alongside other “Bermuda style” variants.

A 6 February 1998 piece did the same—printing multiple versions, including one credited to the Continental Society of Bermuda and another tied to Fred Ming. If you want to see how Bermudians argue about fish-to-potato ratios in real life, these side-by-side recipes show the spectrum: some are potato-forward; others are richer, heavier, and more fish-forward.

Meanwhile, the government foodways guide captures the social side of the argument: “fishy cake” people versus “more potato” people; optional add-ins like celery or curry powder; and even the Good Friday constraint that bacon might be rejected by those keeping the day strictly fish-based.

Hot cross buns exist across the Anglophone world, but the pairing—sweet bun with savoury cod cake—gets flagged as distinctively Bermudian in the foodways guide: “Only in Bermuda will people couple a savoury, salty codfish cake with a sweet hot cross bun.”

It’s also one of those traditions that keeps renewing itself. In March 2025, The Bermudian published a codfish cake video and recipes, explicitly linking the ritual again to Good Friday kite flying and warm hot cross buns—heritage as something you still have to practice, not just remember. 

One more detail in the government guide lands like a quiet update: salted cod “is not the inexpensive meal it once was”—it notes that today it can cost more than ground beef.

That’s the modern version of the same old story. Codfish cakes were, in part, a way to stretch an imported preserved fish with potatoes into something that fed more people. The method still makes sense—even as the economics shift.

What’s less clear—because it requires deeper archival trawling—is how far back the named dish “codfish cakes” goes in Bermuda print culture beyond the late-20th-century newspaper record that’s easy to retrieve. The tradition feels older than its most-circulated recipes, but proving that means going issue-by-issue through older newspapers, diaries, and household records.